I have been on the hunt to find the perfect mascara for years. I have had a few that I liked okay that I would use for a while, and then I would decided that I really don’t like it all that much and try another one. I have used a wide variety of brands in a wide price range including Clinique, Maybelline, Mary Kay, Bare Minerals, Younique, and many more. There was nothing major wrong with any of those brands. It is really all about personal preference and what look you are going for. For me, the wand matters and the clumpiness (I just made up that word) is a big factor for me. That includes clumping on the wand and clumping on my lashes when I apply it. When I started using Rodan + Fields’ Lash Boost and my lashes started to look fuller and longer, I realized my current mascara just wasn’t doing if for me anymore so I was on the hunt for a better mascara. I guess that I should mention that I have deep set eyes so sometimes it is hard to really see my lashes without a good mascara. It’s just the way my eyes are built. On top of that, I wear glasses all day, every day, which also distracts from my lashes. I really need a mascara that is going to make my lashes look longer and fuller.
After getting feedback from several people, I started using Roller Lash by Benefit (Ulta) a couple of years ago. It is said to be “super-curling and lifting” by the maker. I don’t know so much about curling part, but I do feel like it lifted my lashes and helped them to stand out better. I would say that it is a pretty decent mascara, and I was happy with it for a long time. I really feel like it makes my lashes appear longer. The one thing I don’t care for is that it doesn’t really give my lashes a fuller look. I do really like the thin applicator and the way that it glides on so easily. It has very short bristles, and that style works really well for me and is the kind I prefer. I have never had this brand clump on the applicator or on my lashes. I would recommend it to anyone because it is a solid choice, and I really have no major complaints about it other than the fullness factor.
A month or so ago, a friend mentioned a different mascara to me. It is one that has actually been on my list for a while as one to try, but I was in no hurry to purchase it because I was happy with the Roller Lash. Anyway, she convinced me to give it a try. Now, let me first say that my friend has amazing natural lashes that I have always been envious of, so I knew that the mascara wasn’t going to perform for me as well as it does for her. I was willing to give it a try, though. I hopped over to Ulta that same day and purchased Too Faced Better Than Sex (Ulta) mascara. Yes, I wish it had a different name, but it is what it is. When I first opened it up, I could already tell that I wasn’t going to love the applicator. It is big and bushy. It has thick, long bristles and I typically avoid that kind of wand. I was set on giving it a solid try, though. I must say, that although I am still not crazy about the wand, I really like this mascara. Not only does it give me the length, but it also gives my lashes a thicker appearance. I have only been using it for about a month, but so far I am fairly pleased with it. I have this feeling that it could get clumpy, but I am hopeful that it won’t. The jury is still out on that.
I tried to do a side-by-side comparison for you, but it is really hard to photograph my eyes myself, and it just doesn’t translate as well to the picture as it does in real life. However, I think that you can still tell the difference. You can see that the side with the Too Faced mascara is definitely more prominent than the side with the Benefit mascara. While both mascara’s are very different, I would recommend both of them to you as good options for mascara. If you take a look at the two pictures at the beginning of this post where I am wearing the Too Faced mascara in one picture and the Benefit mascara in the other, you can see that they both are good mascaras separately. It is only when you put them side by side with one on each eye that you can really see the difference. Again, it is totally a matter of preference. I am not sure which one I will choose to go with for the long hall because I love them both for different reasons. I love the Benefit Roller Lash because of its applicator and easiness to apply, and I love the Too Faced Better than Sex for the fullness and length it gives my lashes. I also feel like the Benefit mascara gives you a more natural look than the Too Faced mascara. I’m not sure if that matters to me, though. It is really hard to decide which is my absolute favorite. I like them both! You just have to choose the one that works best for you because they are both great options!